Teck decision underscores investment crisis in Canada

Printer-friendly version
Appeared in National Newswatch, February 27, 2020
Teck decision underscores investment crisis in Canada

Canada has massive investment potential. We have an abundance of natural resources, one of the most highly-educated populations in the world, and reside next to the world’s most successful economy. We are also among the freest countries in the world including freedom of religion, assembly, movement and trade.

Simply put, we’re the kind of country that investment should be flocking to in droves. Instead, investment is fleeing our country. And the cancellation of Teck Resources’ $20-billion Frontier oilsands mine is unfortunately just the latest example of investment flight.

On Sunday, just days before the Trudeau government was expected to approve or reject the project, Teck CEO Don Lindsay sent a letter to Jonathan Wilkinson, the federal minister of Environment and Climate Change, saying the company was officially withdrawing its application. For investors, this is more evidence of how politicized the regulatory process for major projects in Canada has become.

The blame lies at the feet of the current federal government, which recently created a new agency, the Impact Assessment Agency of Canada (IAAC), to review major energy projects, injecting significant subjective criteria into project analyses—including “social” impact, gender implications and potential climate effects—and further politicized the process by placing final decisions on approval or rejection in the hands of the federal cabinet.

The government has also created mass uncertainty with unsustainable federal budget deficits, tax increases on high-skilled workers and entrepreneurs, and more burdensome regulations.

As a result, Ottawa has made Canada less competitive and less attractive for entrepreneurs and investors. Which is why Canada has plummeted in “competitiveness” report cards such as the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business report where we dropped from fourth place in 2007 to 23rd in 2020, or the latest World Economic Forum’s Global Competitiveness Report, which ranks Canada 14th compared to second-place United States.

Also worrying is the actual hard investment data.

According to Statistics Canada data, inflation-adjusted business investment in Canada has declined by 5.3 per cent over the past five years. But crucially, if you remove “residential structures” and business investment in machinery and equipment from the equation, investment in intellectual property and non-residential structures has decreased by 13.2 per cent.

And this isn’t just an oil and gas story. There’s been a significant drop in investment across 10 of the 15 major sectors of the Canadian economy including agriculture, mining, utilities, professional and technical services, manufacturing and retail.

Clearly, investors—both foreign and Canadian—are fleeing our country for more favourable investment climates. In total, $150 billion has left Canada from 2014 to 2018. And while final numbers for 2019 are not yet available, data from January to September indicates another $23 billion left in the first nine months of last year.

This has left our investment per worker in Canada ($13,078 in 2018) well below the U.S. number ($22,270) and below the average in the 16 developed OECD countries excluding Canada where data is available ($17,026). Given that investment provides the resources for new equipment, innovation and ultimately sustainable and prosperous employment for Canadians, this is bad news for Canada’s economic prospects.

The bottom line is that Canada is viewed by Canadian and foreign investors as an inhospitable place to invest. When a country or jurisdiction fails to offer a competitive investment environment—or when the rules and policies are uncertain and unstable—businessowners, entrepreneurs and investors look elsewhere.

That’s the tragedy of Canada and the latest decision by Teck Resources. We’re a country with all the natural advantages one could dream of, yet we’re destroying our potential.

Subscribe to the Fraser Institute

Get the latest news from the Fraser Institute on the latest research studies, news and events.